How can we assist you? Book an appointment with us today!

Can Pets Be Tax Dependents? A Legal Battle with the IRS

Tax season raises many questions, but one New York attorney is adding a furry twist: Can pets be legally recognized as dependents? As heartwarming as it sounds to claim your lovable golden retriever as a dependent, the IRS isn’t wagging its tail just yet. Attorney Amanda Reynolds is challenging this notion in federal court.

In December 2025, Reynolds filed a groundbreaking lawsuit against the IRS, alleging that her beloved golden retriever, Finnegan, should be classified as a dependent for federal tax purposes. This daring legal argument revolves around whether the tax code should adapt to modern family dynamics, including non-human members.

The Legal Argument: "Bringing Pets into the Tax Fold"

Reynolds contends that Finnegan satisfies the IRS’s criteria for a dependent because he:

  • Resides with her full-time,

  • Has no income, and

  • Receives more than 50% of his financial support from her, citing over $5,000 in annual expenses.

Image 2

Pushing further, Reynolds claims that classifying dependents solely based on species violates the Equal Protection Clause, proposing that pets hold similar emotional and financial roles in households as their human counterparts.

Current Status of the Case

While the case sits in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, a judge has granted a stay on discovery, with the IRS poised to file a motion to dismiss. Pending the court’s detailed examination, the outcome remains uncertain, posing intriguing questions about the treatment of pets under tax law.

IRS’s View: Why Pets Aren’t Dependents

The tax quandary arises because IRC Section 152 defines dependents as "individuals," a term conventionally interpreted as humans. IRS forms accommodate only human dependents with requisite identification, emphasizing established family and household connections through credits and deductions. Thus, a functional dependency on its own isn't enough to alter these legal definitions.

Image 1

Tax Deductions for Animal-Related Expenses

However, a sliver of tax relief does exist. Here are some scenarios where animal expenses might qualify:

  • Service Animals: Acquiring and maintaining a service animal may count as a medical expense. Service animals must be specifically trained for disability assistance, unlike emotional support animals.
  • Business Animals: Animals serving in business capacities, like guard dogs or pest control on properties, can have associated costs deducted as business expenses, provided the purpose and documentation are legitimate.
  • Foster Animals: Out-of-pocket costs that volunteers incur while fostering animals for charitable organizations can sometimes be written off, as long as contributions meet IRS stipulations.

Conclusion: The Emotional and Taxing Reality

Though the endeavor to claim pets as dependents is met with legal resistance, it underscores an emotional truth for many: pets are family. Yet, until the laws evolve, taxpayers are reminded that deductions must align with current IRS guidelines, and each potential expense should be verified against what’s permissible.

Stay tuned as the courts—set against a backdrop of evolving family definitions—grapple with this novel case. Regardless of the final ruling, it serves as a reminder that while pets are in our hearts and homes, tax codes remain grounded in statutory language and definitions.

Share this article...

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

Affiliations